Skip to content

Horror games with multiple endings on itch.io

32 horror games with multiple endings on itch.io, each with a page on what frightens and a link to where it is sold. The story has two or more distinct endings that depend on the player's choices or actions, as the game or its makers state. A single ending with a bonus scene, or endings only reached by dying, does not count.

32 games

All horror games with multiple endings on itch.io

Yuki Onna key art: the pale hand of a woman in a white kimono reaching out in the dark

[Chilla's Art] Yuki Onna | 雪女

Rescue three children from an abandoned mountain inn, on one life.

PC

a man outside illustration: a dark silhouette of a man standing on a grey pavement between two bare, twisted trees

a man outside

A vocabulary quiz, a quiet street, and a man who keeps standing there.

Browser

Beary the Hatchet: a goth girl with flame sunglasses and the clerk in a white bear mask with blood on his shirt stand in a gas station aisle under Beer and Cigs signs

Multiple endings

Beary the Hatchet

A killer's Halloween shift, a body in the back and a fan at the counter.

PC

CANIDAE: Red in a snarling fox mask with a baseball bat and Blue in a blue animal mask stand in a dark street of houses at night

Multiple endings

CANIDAE

Halloween night, animal masks, and friends who start to change.

Browser / PC / Mac / Linux

Carnivore cover: a wide-eyed cartoon sheep runs with a bloody cleaver across a menu card headed Today's Special

Multiple endings

Carnivore!

You are a sheep, you work in a restaurant, and you are on the menu.

Browser / PC / Mac / Linux

Crowscare cover art: the scarecrow boy Ryo in a straw hat and red scarf, half his face dark with glowing yellow eyes, beside the title

Multiple endings

Crowscare

A straw boy's first Harvest Festival, and the reason he was kept home at night.

PC / Mac / Linux

Dead Plate gameplay: Rody serves tables in the red and cream dining room on day 6, with the clock and order board on the right

Multiple endings

Dead Plate

Wait tables for a week at a 1960s bistro and learn what the chef is hiding.

PC / Mac

FAITH: The Unholy Trinity key art: a priest seen from behind stands before a huge red demon with many clawed arms

Multiple endings

FAITH: The Unholy Trinity

A young priest, a crucifix and the Satanic Panic of the 1980s in 8-bit horror.

PC / PlayStation / Xbox / Switch

Hello Charlotte EP2 key art: Charlotte, a pale girl drawn in black and white, cries against a dark background

Hello Charlotte EP2: Requiem Aeternam Deo

Steer your puppet through the House, the School and a Trial nobody escapes.

PC

Lisa, a smiling girl in a Green Day T-shirt, tells you there's a big Halloween party tonight, with classroom scenes behind her

Multiple endings

Help! I Took My Little Brother to a Halloween Party and the Popular Kids Want to Sacrifice Him to a Demon!

Halloween 2004, a party full of theatre kids, and a demon that wants your little brother.

PC / Mac / Linux

Human Construction Site cover: a red bloodshot eye inside a red warning triangle over dark green growth, with the title in red

Human Construction Site

Wake with no memory in a facility that treats people as specimens.

Browser / PC / Mac

Jake's Halloween Night art: a scratchy drawn jack-o'-lantern with Halloween written across it over dark hills

Multiple endings

Jake's Halloween Night

October 31: get Jake ready for a killer Halloween party.

Browser / PC

Lily's Well key art: a pink outlined stone well with a wooden roof and crank against a black background

Multiple endings

Lily's Well

Someone is calling from the bottom of the well.

PC

Mausoleosis cover: David and a blonde woman holding a teddy bear between gravestone crosses, under a shadowy clawed figure

Mausoleosis

A letter from a mother who has been dead for twenty years.

Browser / PC / Mac

Milk outside a bag of milk outside a bag of milk screenshot: the red-eyed girl in a black sweater looks worried in her dark apartment, with red windows behind her

Milk outside a bag of milk outside a bag of milk

The girl got her milk. Now help her get through the night.

PC / Mac / Linux / Switch

missed messages. screenshot: May, a girl with pink hair and freckles, smiles from a doorway beside a speech bubble thanking you for being her friend

missed messages.

A stranger's phone airdrops you a photo. Accept or decline?

PC / Mac / Linux

Mr. Hopp's Playhouse art: a pixel-art girl with a frightened face against pink patterned wallpaper

Multiple endings

Mr. Hopp's Playhouse

Hide from the toy rabbit you were always afraid of.

PC / iPhone / Android

Mr. Hopp's Playhouse 2 key art: Esther, a girl with a purple headband, looks anxiously aside in a dark wallpapered corridor

Mr. Hopp's Playhouse 2

Three donated toys, two missing friends, and an orphanage with a dark past.

PC / iPhone / Android

Mycopsychosys: Remastered: Silvia, an officer in a gas mask and cap, stands on the porch of a black-and-white street with red spores in the air

Mycopsychosys: Remastered

A spore storm is coming. Stay inside, and decide who you let in.

PC / Mac

Nun Massacre screenshot: the nun with bleeding eyes and a pale face steps out of a dark hallway toward the player, through a VHS filter

Multiple endings

Nun Massacre

A stormy night, a boarding school and a killer nun.

PC / iPhone / PlayStation / Xbox / Switch

Paper Lily key art: Lacie, a blonde girl in a red scarf and white coat, holding a golden letter tangled in red threads

Paper Lily - Chapter 1

Follow a golden letter into a hidden world where every puzzle has another way out.

PC / Mac / Linux

Project Kat screenshot: girls holding a seance at a table in a dark pixel-art room, and a frightened girl saying Is that a ghost? We summoned a ghost

Multiple endings

Project Kat - Paper Lily Prologue

Follow a golden letter into your school after dark.

PC / Mac / Linux

Run to Nowhere title over a black-and-white park path at night lined with trees and street lamps

Multiple endings

RUN TO NOWHERE

A minute-long horror silent film you run through.

Browser / PC / Mac

Seven Mysteries banner: a pale student with a bloodied hand holding a book between a red-lit and a blue-lit top-down school map

Multiple endings

Seven Mysteries

Every secret of the school costs something. Remember the numbers.

PC

Sofia? cover: a dark-haired young man glances sideways while a pale masked figure smeared with blood stands behind him, the title written in pink

Sofia?

A sweet night at your boyfriend's place, until a guest arrives.

Browser / PC

Sorry We're Closed art: a row of neon-coloured demon faces with long tongues and sharp teeth on a dark background

Sorry We're Closed

A cursed shop worker opens her third eye on a neon demon world.

PC / PlayStation / Xbox / Switch

TELEFORUM key art: the widow sits in shadow in an armchair beside a lamp, a side table and a bookcase, in a dark wallpapered room

TELEFORUM

A widow, an interview, and the tape you really came for.

PC / Mac

The Radio Tower screenshot: looking up the steel ladder of the radio mast past a high-voltage sign into a red sky

Multiple endings

The Radio Tower

Climb a radio tower by a quarantined town while something hunts you from the forest.

PC / Linux

The Windows Are Gone key art: a dark house with glowing yellow windows stands among thin blue trees above a field of red grass

The Windows Are Gone

A house from your dreams is calling, and you have just moved in.

PC

Them and Us key art: Alicia holding a pump shotgun beside a misty graveyard of gallows, torches and a stone arch under a blue night sky

Them and Us

One survivor of a 1978 bus crash, and a night that keeps getting stranger.

PC

Therapy with Dr. Albert Krueger key art: Taylor with arms crossed beside the smirking Dr. Krueger in pink and teal light

Therapy with Dr. Albert Krueger

Book a session of patented Dream Therapy. The doctor will see you now.

PC / Mac / Linux

What Grows in the Night title art: the scarecrow girl sits among pumpkins under a bare cross-shaped post with a crow, a shooting star in the dusk sky

Multiple endings

What Grows in the Night

A scarecrow is given life to tend a stranger's garden. The plants grow too well.

PC / Mac / Linux

Guides

Games Like Until Dawn: Choice-Driven Horror