Psychological horrorHorror visual novelsAnime horror
Umineko When They Cry - Answer Arcs
Rate itBack to Rokkenjima for the second half of the witch's murders.
- Platforms
- PC, Mac, Linux
- Stores
- Steam, GOG
- Price
- Paid
- Rated
- Overwhelmingly Positive on Steam (96% of 1,608 reviews); 4.6 of 5 on GOG (10 ratings); 90 from Hardcore Gamer
- Length
- about 57 hours
- Players
- 1
- Made by
- 07th Expansion
- Released
- 2017
No. 9 of the demon horror games · No. 19 of the horror games about family · No. 4 of the witch horror games · No. 12 of the mansion horror games · No. 4 of the murder mystery horror games · No. 5 of the island horror games
What frightens Episodes five to eight return to Rokkenjima on 4 October 1986, where a family fighting over a dying man's fortune is cut off on its island, a letter arrives from someone claiming to be a witch, and brutal murders repeat with unsolvable riddles left at each scene. The dread is in the doubt: whether the killer is one of the eighteen people there, a 19th presence, or a witch.
Content: blood, violence, coarse language, very long read.
Umineko When They Cry - Answer Arcs is the second half of 07th Expansion's murder mystery sound novel, episodes five to eight. You return once more to the Ushiromiya family's island in October 1986, where a self-proclaimed witch's letter is followed by brutal killings, and you read on toward the truth while the puzzle of who, or what, is behind them stays yours to solve.
About Umineko When They Cry - Answer Arcs
Umineko When They Cry (When Seagulls Cry) is a sound novel series by 07th Expansion. The Answer Arcs hold its second half, episodes five through eight, and were released on Steam by MangaGamer on 17 November 2017 for Windows, Mac and Linux; it is also sold DRM-free on GOG. This version lets you swap between the renewed character sprites and the originals, keeps the original music, is uncut, and can be read in English or Japanese. It has no voice acting: everything is text, art and music.
It picks up straight after the Question Arcs, which hold episodes one to four and are sold separately; start there. Once again it is 4 October 1986 on Rokkenjima, the island where the Ushiromiya family holds its yearly conference. The old head of the family has little life left, his children want his fortune and the ten tons of gold he is said to have hidden, and a riddle on an epitaph is said to point to it. A letter comes from someone calling herself a witch, and the sense of a 19th person on an island that should hold 18 hangs over everything.
The murders that follow are brutal and leave riddles no one can explain. You do not fight or make choices: you read, and the challenge the game sets is to work out for yourself whether the culprit is human or a witch. In its makers' words, the Answer Arcs will teach you many things, but solving the mystery of the epitaph is still up to you. Hardcore Gamer's review notes that these episodes still replay the family conference and peel the mystery away bit by bit, while other witches, Bernkastel and Lambdadelta among them, step forward to challenge Battler.
It mixes family drama, comedy, debates between the characters and true horror in its killings and in the witch's taunts. It is very long: HowLongToBeat puts the main story at about 57 and a half hours. It is for readers who finished the first half and want the rest of the story, and who like long mysteries told through text, music and art.
How to play Umineko When They Cry - Answer Arcs
- Read Umineko When They Cry - Question Arcs first; the Answer Arcs continue its story.
- Install the Answer Arcs from Steam or GOG and start from episode five.
- Click or press a key to move the text forward, reading the story as it unfolds.
- Swap between the renewed and original character art, and between English and Japanese text, if you prefer.
- Keep your own theory of the murders as you read; the game leaves solving the epitaph to you.
Screenshots





Tips
- Keep notes on who was where at each murder; the story wants you to try to solve it.
- Do not look up the story online while you read; the second half is easily spoiled.
- Auto mode is slow and has no speed setting, so most readers click through at their own pace with the music on.
- Read it in sessions of an episode or part of one; the main story alone runs to more than fifty hours.
Questions
Do I need to read the Question Arcs first?
Yes. The Answer Arcs are the second half of the series, episodes five to eight, and follow straight on from the Question Arcs.
How long is Umineko When They Cry - Answer Arcs?
HowLongToBeat, as shown on its GOG page, puts the main story at about 57 and a half hours, and about 70 hours for everything.
Is Umineko a horror game?
It is a murder mystery sound novel with strong horror: brutal killings on a cut-off island and a witch who may be behind them. Steam and GOG players tag it horror and psychological horror, and its store page warns of blood and violence.
Does it have choices or voice acting?
No to both. It is a linear sound novel read in text, with music and character art; the challenge is working out the mystery yourself.
What languages can I read it in?
English and Japanese, according to the Steam page.
Ratings and reviews
If Umineko When They Cry - Answer Arcs frightened you
Umineko When They Cry - Question Arcs
The first half of the same story, episodes one to four: read it before the Answer Arcs.
PC / Mac / Linux
Higurashi When They Cry Hou - Ch.1 Onikakushi
07th Expansion's earlier sound novel, free to start: a quiet village where someone dies and…
PC / Mac / Linux
Return to Shironagasu Island
Another anime murder mystery on an island: a dead millionaire's invitation, a mansion and a…
PC / Mac / Switch / iPhone
The House in Fata Morgana
A long, story-first visual novel of a cursed mansion and family tragedy, praised like Umineko…
PC / PlayStation / Switch / iPhone / Android
Raging Loop
A Japanese horror visual novel where a cut-off community is killed one by one and you look for…
PC / PlayStation / Xbox / Switch
SILENT HILL f
A story by Ryukishi07, Umineko's author: a fog-bound 1960s Japanese town where the heroine…
PC / PlayStation / Xbox
The Incident at Galley House
A deadly night at a country house to piece together from clues, more mystery than chase.
PC / Mac / Linux
Bad Faith
A sanctuary on an island, its punishments, and a building in the woods.
PC / Mac / Linux
More psychological horror games
- [Chilla's Art] Inunaki Tunnel | 犬鳴トンネル
- [Chilla's Art] Jisatsu | 自撮
- [Chilla's Art] Missing Children | 行方不明
- [Chilla's Art] Night Delivery | 例外配達
- [Chilla's Art] Night Security | 夜間警備
- [Chilla's Art] Okaeri | おかえり
- [Chilla's Art] Parasocial
- [Chilla's Art] Shinkansen 0 | 新幹線 0号
- [Chilla's Art] Stigmatized Property | 事故物件
- [Chilla's Art] The Caregiver | 終焉介護
- [Chilla's Art] The Closing Shift | 閉店事件
- [Chilla's Art] The Convenience Store | 夜勤事件